Cllr Sean Maher: Argued that the people of Offaly want to keep the triple lock.

Heated council debate on 'triple lock' removal

By Rebekah O'Reilly

A heated debate about the potential removal of the so-called 'triple lock' was held at the most recent meeting of Offaly County Council, as councillors debated its impact on Ireland's military neutrality.

The discussion arose as Sinn Féin Cllr Sean Maher brought a motion asking the council to write to the Taoiseach’s office outlining the importance of the triple lock mechanism and to request the Government re-consider its position on this matter and not alter the legal provision to Ireland’s neutrality".

The triple lock is an Irish legal mechanism that requires UN approval, a decision by Government, and a vote in the Dáil, before the Government can deploy more than 12 members of the Irish Defence Forces on overseas military or peacekeeping operations.

Legislation to scrap the triple lock recently passed its first vote in the Dáil after 79 TDs backed the change and 71 opposed it. The bill is set to be further scrutinised at the committee stage.

"The triple lock is closely associated with Ireland's traditional policy of military neutrality. Removing this mechanism may impact the foundation for Irish foreign policy," said Cllr Maher.

"For over 90 years we've had this proud tradition of neutrality. (The triple lock) is there to protect our neutrality, and the people of Offaly want to keep it."

Independent Ireland Cllr Fergus Mc Donnell seconded the motion, saying it was important that councillors "reflect public feeling".

"We need to remember where the triple lock came from. [Micheál Martin] is on the record in 2013 speaking in support of the triple lock, now there's been a complete u-tturn. People are fearful when it comes to doing away with a guarantee in the constitution for people to have a say."

Speaking in support of the removal of the triple lock, Fine Gael's Cllr Neil Feighery said Ireland's military neutrality would remain intact.

"We have to allow the possibility of other peacekeeping missions," he said, making reference to the ending of the Lebanon mission, and the lack of new mission approvals in recent years.

"Russia and China have continued to block peacekeeping missions, Ireland needs to continue its role as a key peacekeeping," he said.

Noting her support for Cllr Maher's motion, Sinn Féin Cllr Claire Murray said there had been a "shift away from peacekeeping and towards enforcing".

"We need to be very clear here: it is an important safeguard in how Ireland practices its military neutrality. Whose interests would they be serving? Our soldiers have gained international recognition as peacekeepers. Peacekeeping is not a weakness."

Fianna Fáil Cllr Claire Murray Smale said it was a "false narrative" to say that the removal of the triple lock would impact neutrality, calling the claim "fearmongering, hyperbole, and clickbait".

"It's something I feel extremely strongly about, it's something many Irish people feel very strongly about," stated Sinn Féin Cllr Aoife Masterson.

Cllr Masterson referred to the Nice Treaty referendum in October 2002, when the Irish government issued a national declaration at the Seville European Council which reaffirmed Ireland's traditional policy of military neutrality.

"We cannot rewrite history, we cannot say that the commitment made in 2002 was meaningless," she said. "People relied on it when they voted, the same parties that made this commitment are now looking to have it overturned is appalling. This is not a question of hyperbole, it has real life impacts and real human rights impacts."

Independent Cllr Sean O Brien said he doesn't see anything in the proposed change that would impact neutrality, and that change was required.

He also made reference to the involvement of Russia and China in the UN as a reason for the proposed change.

"We live in a different world. The fact Russia would have a say in anything we would do is ludicrous. My gut feeling is that we have to change it.”

A counter motion stating that Offaly County Council supports the Defence Amendment to remove the triple lock was proposed, and it passed on a vote of 15 in favour and four against.